Blind Date with a Cookie
Where sometimes the best things in life are a little unexpected.
Swipe & Reveal Your Cookie Match
Swipe right or tap Match to tear open the sealed profile and reveal your mystery cookie!
How Cookie Dating Works
Meet Your Match In Person
October 17, 2026 (Saturday)
8:00 AM – 12:30 PM
Right near Bowl 91, College Avenue, Downtown Appleton, WI
Members earn sweet points on every blind date match & get first pick of surprise flavors!
The Envelope & The Reveal
Here’s how a Blind Date with a Cookie actually works in real life!
Sealed Dating Profile Envelope
Every cookie comes packaged with its very own dating profile—complete with hints about its personality, cravings, and flavor profile. Read the clues and see who catches your eye!
Unbox Your Match In Real Life
You won’t know exactly what freshly baked flavor is inside until you open your envelope in real life! Grab your sealed favorites at our weekend market pop-ups or order for your next celebration.
Have you ever heard of a Blind Date with a Cookie?
Come experience your very own Blind Date with a Cookie this weekend at the Appleton Farmers Market!
I’ll have all your favorite cookies available, PLUS my Blind Date cookies! Each one comes packaged with its very own dating profile—complete with little hints about the cookie’s personality and flavor.
But there’s a catch… You won’t know exactly what flavor you’re getting until you buy it and open it! Will it be your perfect match? Will it be a total surprise? There’s only one way to find out!
Come find your cookie match!
Fresh Baked Cookies
From classic favorites to creative creations at the market.
