Sugar on the Shelf Orders & Pre-Orders

How to Place an Order

We take orders directly via Facebook Message or Email. Whether you need Halloween DIY cookie kits, Thanksgiving cupcakes & fall trays, Christmas cookies & holiday trays, custom giant cookie cakes, or artisan breads, reach out below!

Message Us on Facebook Email [email protected]

“Homemade with love, baked with faith” • Appleton, Wisconsin

🎃 Halloween DIY Kits ($15 & $25) 🦃 Thanksgiving Pre-Orders (11/25) 🎅🏼 Christmas Pre-Orders (12/19 & 12/23)

Halloween, Thanksgiving & Christmas Pre-Orders Open!

Reserve your Halloween DIY Sugar Cookie Kits (pickup Oct 30), Thanksgiving Fall Cupcakes & Assorted Cookie Trays (available Nov 25), and Christmas Cookies for Santa & Holiday Trays (available Dec 19 & Dec 23)!

View Seasonal Kits & Menus →

Two Ways to Connect Meet the Baker →

Order Direct with the Baker

Pick your preferred channel to place a custom order, inquire about event dates, or reserve holiday boxes. Want to learn more about our kitchen and faith story? Read our story →

1. Facebook Message (Fastest)

Send a direct message on the Sugar on the Shelf Facebook page with what you'd like, desired pickup date, and quantities.

💡 Tip for Pre-Orders: Message your requested Halloween DIY Kit ($15/$25), Thanksgiving Cupcakes or Fall Cookie Tray (11/25), or Christmas Cookies for Santa & Holiday Trays (12/19 & 12/23)!

Message on Facebook →