How to Place an Order
We take orders directly via Facebook Message or Email. Whether you need Christmas pre-orders, custom giant cookie cakes, cookie dozens, or artisan breads, reach out below!
“Homemade with love, baked with faith” • Appleton, WisconsinCookies for Santa & 15-Cookie Holiday Trays
Limited batch sizes available for Dec 19 & Dec 23 pickup! Check out our seasonal page for full menu details and pricing.
Order Direct with the Baker
Pick your preferred channel to place a custom order, inquire about event dates, or reserve holiday boxes. Want to learn more about our kitchen and faith story? Read our story →
1. Facebook Message (Fastest)
Send a direct message on the Sugar on the Shelf Facebook page with what you'd like, desired pickup date, and quantities.
2. Email Inquiry
Prefer email? Send your treat list, event details, and questions directly to [email protected].
Giant Decorated Cookie Cakes
Giant scratch-baked cookie cakes decorated with rich piped buttercream frosting and custom borders for birthdays, graduations, and milestones.
Artisan Cookies & Blind Date Packs
Available by the dozen, multi-pack boxes, or individually packaged Blind Date envelopes. Gluten-friendly cookies available!
Fresh Artisan Breads & Cinnamon Rolls
Golden hearth artisan bread loaves and warm iced cinnamon rolls (gluten-friendly rolls available upon request).