Find Us in Appleton, WI
Contact & Market Schedule
Have a question about Blind Date flavors, custom party cupcakes, or where to find our booth this weekend? Reach out to us directly by email or catch us at local pop-ups!
“Homemade with love, baked with faith” • Appleton, Wisconsin Primary Point of Contact
Direct Email Inquiries
We operate via direct email communications! Whether you have questions about Blind Date flavor drops, allergy/gluten-friendly options, pop-up events, or custom bakery requests, send an email directly to our inbox.
General & Market Questions
[email protected]Cake & Treat Order Requests
[email protected]We reply as soon as the oven timers go off and treats are cooled!
Looking for custom pre-orders? Check our Order Guide.
Where to Find Us
Market & Pop-Up Schedule
Find Sugar on the Shelf at local pop-ups, events, and Downtown Appleton markets throughout the Fox Valley!
Downtown Appleton Farmers Market & Pop-Up EventsCollege Avenue, Downtown Appleton, WI & Local Pop-Ups
Select Pop-Up & Drop-In DatesCheck Facebook Events for Dates & Times
Booth Details:Sugar on the Shelf pop-up booth featuring fresh cookies, Blind Date cookies, breads, cinnamon rolls, and bakery treats.