Fox Valley Service Areas
From our home bakery kitchen in Appleton, we are blessed to bake celebration cakes, gourmet cookies, and artisan breads for families and events throughout the Fox Cities.
“Homemade with love, baked with faith” • Homemade with love, baked with faith
Handcrafted With Love for Fox Valley Gatherings
We started Sugar on the Shelf right here in the heart of the Fox Cities with a simple mission: bringing people together through freshly baked, artisanal sweets baked with faith. Whether you are hosting a birthday party in Neenah, picking up weekend sourdough in Grand Chute, or seeking the original Blind Date with a Cookie in Appleton, our kitchen is here for you.
Orders are freshly prepared for agreed pickup in Appleton with easy contactless porch pickup, or caught at the Downtown Appleton Farmers Market during seasonal dates.
Select Your Community
Click your city to view customized menu favorites, local pickup details, and celebration treats tailored for your neighborhood.
Appleton, WI
Appleton, WI Bakery & Custom Treats
Home base for Sugar on the Shelf and the original Blind Date with a Cookie. Offering custom celebration cakes, cookie packs, fresh breads, and local Appleton pick-up.
Neenah, WI
Neenah, WI Bakery & Custom Treats
Just a quick drive south on I-41, we proudly bake for Neenah families, lakefront parties, corporate events, and weekend gatherings with custom cakes and fresh cookies.
Menasha, WI
Menasha, WI Bakery & Custom Treats
Serving our neighbors in Menasha with small-batch, faith-based home baking. From mystery Blind Date cookies to decorated celebration cakes, we make every event sweet.
Grand Chute, WI
Grand Chute, WI Bakery & Custom Treats
Whether you are near Fox River Mall or nestled in the Grand Chute neighborhoods, our Appleton kitchen supplies the freshest cookies, cupcakes, and celebration cakes.
Kimberly, WI
Kimberly, WI Bakery & Custom Treats
Baking sweet memories for the Heart of the Valley! We craft celebration cakes, decorated cookie cakes, and fresh cinnamon rolls for Kimberly families and events.
Fox Valley Bakery Questions
How do pickups work from Neenah, Menasha, or Kimberly?
Our bakery kitchen is centrally located in Appleton. When your custom cake, cookie pack, or bread order is confirmed, we provide a private pickup window with contactless porch pickup so you can easily swing by at your convenience.
Do you offer gluten-friendly options across all service areas?
Yes! We offer gluten-friendly cookies and cinnamon rolls. Please note our kitchen is not a certified celiac-safe facility, so items are prepared as gluten-friendly with careful handling.
How far in advance should I order for a party?
We recommend 1 to 2 weeks for custom celebration cakes and giant cookie cakes, especially for weekend birthdays or graduation season. Standard cookie packs and seasonal boxes can often be accommodated with 3 to 5 days notice!