Fresh Home-Baked Treats & Custom Cakes in Appleton, WI
Home base for Sugar on the Shelf and the original Blind Date with a Cookie. Offering custom celebration cakes, cookie packs, fresh breads, and local Appleton pick-up.
“Homemade with love, baked with faith” • Handcrafted small-batch baking in the Fox Cities
Baking Fresh For Your Life Celebrations
Whether you are planning a themed birthday party, welcoming family for Sunday dinner, or want a fun sweet surprise, we bring scratch-made bakery goodness straight to your table. Every batch is prepared with premium ingredients, careful attention to detail, and a touch of faith.
Pickup Information for Appleton
Pickup Method: Convenient, contactless local porch pickup arranged upon order confirmation in Appleton.
Popular Gatherings: Birthdays, downtown market visits, school milestones, and weekend family sweet treats.
Popular Treats in Appleton
Handcrafted baked goods ordered most frequently for local parties, celebrations, and weekend family cravings.
Blind Date with a Cookie
Mystery cookies sealed in playful dating profile envelopes (like “The Hopeless Romantic” or “The Night Owl”). A huge hit for gifts and dinner parties!
Celebration & Cookie Cakes
From giant decorated cookie cakes with piped buttercream borders to custom Labubu and birthday cakes handcrafted for your milestone event.
Breads & Cinnamon Rolls
Warm crusty artisan loaves, braided treats, and rich frosted cinnamon rolls. Gluten-friendly options available upon request!